Supplementary Files
Keywords
social-ecological systems
participatory modeling
fuzzy cognitive mapping
benefit-cost analysis
How to Cite
Abstract
Evaluating coping strategies for community resilience planning in the face of natural hazards and disasters presents significant challenges, including limited system clarity, diverging community priorities, resource inequalities, and inherent uncertainties. Traditional methods — often reliant on economic metrics through benefit-cost analysis — primarily assess monetary aspects, overlooking critical non-monetary factors. The increasing shift towards transdisciplinary methods underscores the importance of integrating local community values into resilience planning. This research introduces the Co-DECIDR (Community-informed Decisions for Equitable, Cost-effective, and Inclusive Disaster Resilience) modeling framework, designed to evaluate resilience planning alternatives by embracing community-identified values, leveraging local insights, navigating uncertainties, and balancing monetary with non-monetary considerations. By merging Fuzzy Cognitive Mapping (FCM) for qualitative depth with Benefit-Cost Analysis (BCA) for quantitative rigor, Co-DECIDR enables a comprehensive understanding of complex social-ecological systems. The framework utilizes accessible online tools — Mental Modeler for FCM and Economic Decision Guide Software (EDGe$) for BCA — to enhance user engagement and model efficacy. Demonstrated through proof-of-concept examples in Flint, Michigan, focusing on resilience to extreme weather events and pandemics like COVID-19, this study showcases Co-DECIDR’s practicality and adaptability in real-world contexts. These examples highlight the framework's capacity to support informed, community-centric, and equitable resilience planning. Furthermore, Co-DECIDR advances good modeling practice by utilizing participatory modeling in resilience planning to bridge the gap between modelers and end-users. It systematically captures stakeholder requirements, investigates subjectivity, addresses collaborative modeling challenges, encourages the engagement of diverse groups, and adopts a comprehensive approach to assessing model performance, embracing both qualitative and quantitative criteria.
References
Abdullah, M. F., Siraj, S., & Hodgett, R. E. (2021). An overview of multi-criteria decision analysis (MCDA) application in managing water-related disaster events: analyzing 20 years of literature for flood and drought events. Water, 13(10), 1358.
Alaimo, K., Packnett, E., Miles, R. A., & Kruger, D. J. (2008). Fruit and vegetable intake among urban community gardeners. Journal of Nutrition Education and Behavior, 40(2), 94-101.
Anderson, G. B., & Bell, M. L. (2011). Heat waves in the United States: mortality risk during heat waves and effect modification by heat wave characteristics in 43 US communities. Environmental Health Perspectives, 119(2), 210-218.
Belisle-Toler, R., Hodbod, J., & Wentworth, C. (2021). A mixed methods approach to exploring values that inform desirable food-systems futures. Sustainability: Science, Practice and Policy, 17(1), 362-376.
Bell, A., & Taylor, D. E. (2023). A Vanishing Food Infrastructure: The Closure of Food Outlets in Flint in a Pandemic Era. American Behavioral Scientist, 00027642221142202.
Benromdhane, S. A. (2021). A multi-attribute utility model for environmental decision-making: an application to casting. Environment Systems and Decisions, 41, 21-32.
Berger, L., & Marinacci, M. (2020). Model uncertainty in climate change economics: A review and proposed framework for future research. Environmental and Resource Economics, 77(3), 475-501.
Bingham, A. J., & Witkowsky, P. (2021). Deductive and inductive approaches to qualitative data analysis. In: Analyzing and interpreting qualitative data: After the interview, 133-146. SAGE Publication
Boardman, A. E., Greenberg, D. H., Vining, A. R., & Weimer, D. L. (2018). Cost-Benefit Analysis: Concepts and Practice (5th Edition). Cambridge University Press.
Bostick, T. P., Holzer, T. H., & Sarkani, S. (2017). Enabling stakeholder involvement in coastal disaster resilience planning. Risk analysis, 37(6), 1181-1200.
Bottero, M., Datola, G., & De Angelis, E. (2020). A system dynamics model and analytic network process: an integrated approach to investigate urban resilience. Land, 9(8), 242.
Bureau of Labor Statistics, U.S. Department of Labor, The Economics Daily, Prices for food at home up 13.5 percent for year ended August 2022 at https://www.bls.gov/opub/ted/2022/prices-for-food-at-home-up-13-5-percent-for-year-ended-august-2022.htm.
Buzby, J. C., & Hyman, J. (2012). Total and per capita value of food loss in the United States. Food Policy, 37(5), 561-570.
Chollett, I., Escovar‐Fadul, X., Schill, S. R., Croquer, A., Dixon, A. M., Beger, M., Shaver, E., McNulty, V. P.,& Wolff, N. H. (2022). Planning for resilience: Incorporating scenario and model uncertainty and trade‐offs when prioritizing management of climate refugia. Global Change Biology, 28(13), 4054-4068.
Ciroth, A., Winter, S., & Berlin, G. (2014). openLCA 1.4 overview and first steps. GreenDelta, Berlin, Vol. 174.
CJIC. (2021). Statewide Traffic Crash Data Year End Report. Michigan State Police Retrieved from https://www.michigan.gov/msp/-/media/Project/Websites/msp/cjic/Traffic-Crash-Reporting-Unit-Files/Year-End-Reports/CJIC---Annual-Crash-Report-Year-End-2021.pdf
De Luca, A. I., Iofrida, N., Leskinen, P., Stillitano, T., Falcone, G., Strano, A., & Gulisano, G. (2017). Life cycle tools combined with multi-criteria and participatory methods for agricultural sustainability: Insights from a systematic and critical review. Science of the Total Environment, 595, 352-370.
Dodgson, J. S., Spackman, M., Pearman, A., & Phillips, L. D. (2009). Multi-criteria analysis: a manual. London School of Economics and Political Science, Department of Economic History: London, UK
DOE. (2013). Economic Benefits of Increasing Electric Grid Resilience to Weather Outages. Retrieved from https://www.energy.gov/sites/prod/files/2013/08/f2/Grid%20Resiliency%20Report_FINAL.pdf.
Douthat, T. H., Akhter, F., Sanderson, R., & Penn, J. (2023). Stakeholder Perceptions about Incorporating Externalities and Vulnerability into Benefit–Cost Analysis Tools for Watershed Flood Risk Mitigation. Sustainability, 15(9), 7473.
EPA. (2016). What Climate Change Means for Michigan. Retrieved from https://nepis.epa.gov/Exe/ZyPURL.cgi?Dockey=P100QV9I.txt.
Farrow, S., & von Winterfeldt, D. (2020). Retrospective Benefit–Cost Analysis of Security-Enhancing and Cost-Saving Technologies. Journal of Benefit-Cost Analysis, 11(3), 479-500.
Galanakis, C. M. (2020). The food systems in the era of the coronavirus (COVID-19) pandemic crisis. Foods, Vol. 9(4), pp. 523.
Gilbert, S., & Ayyub, B. M. (2016). Models for the Economics of Resilience. ASCE-ASME Journal of Risk and Uncertainty in Engineering Systems, Part A: Civil Engineering, 2(4), 04016003.
Goepel, K. D. (2018). Implementation of an online software tool for the analytic hierarchy process (AHP-OS). International Journal of the Analytic Hierarchy Process, Vol. 10 (3), pp. 469-487
Gomes, L. S., Santos, S. P., Coelho, L. S., & Rebelo, E. L. (2023). Using MCDA to assist an Intermunicipal community develop a resilience strategy in face of the pandemic caused by the SARS-CoV-2. Socio-Economic Planning Sciences, 87, 101588.
Gray, S. A., Gray, S., Cox, L. J., & Henly-Shepard, S. (2013a). Mental modeler: a fuzzy-logic cognitive mapping modeling tool for adaptive environmental management. In 2013 46th Hawaii International Conference on System Sciences (pp. 965-973). IEEE.
Gray, S. A., Zanre, E., & Gray, S. R. (2013b). Fuzzy cognitive maps as representations of mental models and group beliefs. In Fuzzy cognitive maps for applied sciences and engineering: From fundamentals to extensions and learning algorithms (pp. 29-48). Berlin, Heidelberg: Springer Berlin Heidelberg.
Gray, S. A., Gray, S., De Kok, J. L., Helfgott, A. E., O'Dwyer, B., Jordan, R., & Nyaki, A. (2015). Using fuzzy cognitive mapping as a participatory approach to analyze change, preferred states, and perceived resilience of social-ecological systems. Ecology and Society, Vol. 20(2).
Gray, S., Voinov, A., Paolisso, M., Jordan, R., BenDor, T., Bommel, P., Glynn, P., Hedelin, B., Hubacek, K., Introne, J. & Zellner, M. (2018). Purpose, processes, partnerships, and products: four Ps to advance participatory socio‐environmental modeling. Ecological applications, 28(1), 46-61.
Gu, D., Dillard, M., Gerst, M., & Loerzel, J. (2023). Validating commonly used indicators for community resilience measurement. Natural Hazards Review, 24(2), 04023008.
Guillaume, J. H., Helgeson, C., Elsawah, S., Jakeman, A. J., & Kummu, M. (2017). Toward best practice framing of uncertainty in scientific publications: A review of Water Resources Research abstracts. Water Resources Research, 53(8), 6744-6762.
Hamilton, S. H., Pollino, C. A., Stratford, D. S., Fu, B., & Jakeman, A. J. (2022). Fit-for-purpose environmental modeling: Targeting the intersection of usability, reliability and feasibility. Environmental Modelling & Software, 148, 105278.
Helgeson, J. F., Grubb, S. A., & Webb, D. H. (2017). The Economic Decision Guide Software (EDGeS) Tool: User Guidance.
Helgeson, J., & Li, J. (2022). New Ways to Get to High Ground. Issues in Science and Technology, 38(2), 64-67.
Helgeson, J., & O’Fallon, C. (2021). Resilience dividends and resilience windfalls: Narratives that tie disaster resilience co-benefits to long-term sustainability. Sustainability, 13(8), 4554.
Hendy, K., Mauri, A. I., & Creary, M. (2023). Bounded Equity: The Limits of Economic Models of Social Justice in Cannabis Legislation. Contemporary Drug Problems, 50(1), 121-135.
Hodbod, J., & Wentworth, C. (2022). Assessing Panarchy in Food Systems: Cross-Scale Interactions in Flint, Michigan. Applied Panarchy: Applications and Diffusion Across Disciplines, Vol. 227.
Jablonski, B. B., Casnovsky, J., Clark, J. K., Cleary, R., Feingold, B., Freedman, D., Gray, S., Romeiko, X., Olabisi, L.S., Torres, M. and van den Berg, A.E.,& Wentworth, C. (2021). Emergency food provision for children and families during the COVID‐19 pandemic: examples from five US cities. Applied Economic Perspectives and Policy, 43(1), 169-184.
Jakeman, A. J., El Sawah, S., Cuddy, S., Robson, B., McIntyre, N., & Cook, F. (2018). QWMN Good Modelling Practice Principles.
Jakeman, A. J., Letcher, R. A., & Norton, J. P. (2006). Ten iterative steps in development and evaluation of environmental models. Environmental Modelling & Software, 21(5), 602-614.
Jaramillo, L. V., Stone, M. C., & Benson, M. H. (2021). Developing Factors Developing factors for Socio-Ecohydrological Resilience. In Handbook of disaster risk reduction for resilience: New frameworks for building resilience to disasters (pp. 387-416). Cham: Springer International Publishing.
Jetter, A., & Schweinfort, W. (2011). Building scenarios with Fuzzy Cognitive Maps: An exploratory study of solar energy. Futures, 43(1), 52-66.
Kannan, D., Moazzeni, S., mostafayi Darmian, S., & Afrasiabi, A. (2021). A hybrid approach based on MCDM methods and Monte Carlo simulation for sustainable evaluation of potential solar sites in east of Iran. Journal of Cleaner Production, 279, 122368.
Kiker, G. A., Bridges, T. S., Varghese, A., Seager, T. P., & Linkov, I. (2005). Application of multicriteria decision analysis in environmental decision making. Integrated environmental assessment and management: An International Journal, 1(2), 95-108.
Knox, C. B., Gray, S., Zareei, M., Wentworth, C., Aminpour, P., Wallace, R. V., Hodbod, J., & Brugnone, N. (2023). Modeling complex problems by harnessing the collective intelligence of local experts: New approaches in fuzzy cognitive mapping. Collective Intelligence, 2(4), 26339137231203582.
Koliou, M., van de Lindt, J. W., McAllister, T. P., Ellingwood, B. R., Dillard, M., & Cutler, H. (2020). State of the research in community resilience: Progress and challenges. Sustainable and resilient infrastructure, 5(3), 131-151.
Lambrou, N., & Loukaitou-Sideris, A. (2022). Resilience plans in the US: an evaluation. Journal of Environmental Planning and Management, 65(5), 809-832.
Levin, S., Xepapadeas, T., Crépin, A. S., Norberg, J., De Zeeuw, A., Folke, C., Hughes, T., Arrow, K., Barrett, S., Daily, G. & Walker, B. (2013). Social-ecological systems as complex adaptive systems: modeling and policy implications. Environment and Development Economics, 18(2), 111-132.
Lewis, M., Herron, L. M., Chatfield, M. D., Tan, R. C., Dale, A., Nash, S., & Lee, A. J. (2023). Healthy food prices increased more than the prices of Unhealthy Options during the COVID-19 Pandemic and Concurrent Challenges to the Food System. International Journal of Environmental Research and Public Health, 20(4), 3146.
Maliene, V., Dixon-Gough, R., & Malys, N. (2018). Dispersion of relative importance values contributes to the ranking uncertainty: Sensitivity analysis of Multiple Criteria Decision-Making methods. Applied Soft Computing, 67, 286-298.
Marani, M., Katul, G. G., Pan, W. K., & Parolari, A. J. (2021). Intensity and frequency of extreme novel epidemics. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences, 118(35), e2105482118.
Masson-Minock, M., & Stockmann, D. (2010). Creating a legal framework for urban agriculture: Lessons from Flint, Michigan. Journal of Agriculture, Food Systems, and Community Development, 1(2), 91-104.
Mavrotas, G., & Makryvelios, E. (2021). Combining multiple criteria analysis, mathematical programming and Monte Carlo simulation to tackle uncertainty in Research and Development project portfolio selection: A case study from Greece. European Journal of Operational Research, 291(2), 794-806.
McAllister, T. P. (2015). Community resilience planning guide for buildings and infrastructure systems, Volume I, Special Publication (NIST SP), National Institute of Standards and Technology, Gaithersburg, MD, Retrieved from https://doi.org/10.6028/NIST.SP.1190v1
McWethy, D. B., Schoennagel, T., Higuera, P. E., Krawchuk, M., Harvey, B. J., Metcalf, E. C., Buma, B., & Kolden, C. (2019). Rethinking resilience to wildfire. Nature Sustainability, 2(9), 797-804.
MDHHS. (2018). MiTracking: Michigan Environmental Public Health Tracking Accessed at: https://www.michigan.gov/mdhhs/safety-injury-prev/environmental-health/topics/mitracking.
Meerow, S., & Newell, J. P. (2021). Urban resilience for whom, what, when, where, and why?. In Geographic Perspectives on Urban Sustainability (pp. 43-63). Routledge.
Michigan Food Security Council. (2022). Food Security Council Final Report. Retrieved from https://www.michigan.gov/mdhhs/-/media/Project/Websites/mdhhs/Folder1/Folder101/FSC_Final_Report1_749248_7.pdf?rev=c44349d37dfc4e1d818d5a6e2218545b&hash=A83C943059FB7C91079460E4C5905F1E
Miles, S. B. (2018). Participatory disaster recovery simulation modeling for community resilience planning. International Journal of Disaster Risk Science, 9, 519-529.
Mls, K., Kořínek, M., Štekerová, K., Tučník, P., Bureš, V., Čech, P., Husakova, M., Mikulecký, P., Nacházel, T., Ponce, D. and Zanker, M & Triantafyllou, I. (2023). Agent-based models of human response to natural hazards: systematic review of tsunami evacuation. Natural hazards, Vol. 115(3), pp. 1887-1908.
MTA. (2023). Flint Mass Transportation Authority, Financial Report with Supplemental Information. Retrieved from https://www.mtaflint.org/wp-content/media/63148-Mass-Transportation-Authority-0923-Final-Financial-Audit-Report.pdf
Neely, C. L., Bourne, M., Chesterman, S., Vågen, T. G., Lekaram, V., Winowiecki, L. A., & Prabhu, R. (2021). Inclusive, cross-sectoral and evidence-based decision-making for resilience planning and decision-making in a devolved context. The European Journal of Development Research, 33(4), 1115-1140.
NOAA. (2023). Global Historical Climatology Network-Daily. In: National Centers for Environmental Information Retrieved from https://www.ncei.noaa.gov/access/monitoring/monthly-report/global/202313
Ober Allen, J., Alaimo, K., Elam, D., & Perry, E. (2008). Growing vegetables and values: Benefits of neighborhood-based community gardens for youth development and nutrition. Journal of Hunger & Environmental Nutrition, 3(4), 418-439.
O'Hara, S., & Toussaint, E. C. (2021). Food access in crisis: Food security and COVID-19. Ecological Economics, 180, 106859.
Perz, S. G., Muñoz-Carpena, R., Kiker, G., & Holt, R. D. (2013). Evaluating ecological resilience with global sensitivity and uncertainty analysis. Ecological Modelling, 263, 174-186.
Proag, V., (2021). Analysis of Environmental Impacts of Infrastructure. In: Infrastructure Planning and Management: An Integrated Approach, Springer, Cham. https://doi.org/10.1007/978-3-030-48559-7_8
Raciborski, R. A., Woodward, E. N., & Painter, J. T. (2022). Economic analyses of behavioral health intervention implementation: Perspective on stakeholder engagement. Frontiers in Psychiatry, 13, 1031325.
Rezvani, S. M., de Almeida, N. M., & Falcão, M. J. (2023). Climate Adaptation Measures for Enhancing Urban Resilience. Buildings, 13(9), 2163.
Rising, J. A., Taylor, C., Ives, M. C., & Ward, R. E. (2022). Challenges and innovations in the economic evaluation of the risks of climate change. Ecological Economics, 197, 107437.
Roach, T., Kapelan, Z., & Ledbetter, R. (2018). A resilience-based methodology for improved water resources adaptation planning under deep uncertainty with real world application. Water resources management, 32, 2013-2031.
Rogers, A. A., Dempster, F. L., Hawkins, J. I., Johnston, R. J., Boxall, P. C., Rolfe, J., Kragt, M. E., Burton, M. P., & Pannell, D. J. (2019). Valuing non-market economic impacts from natural hazards. Natural Hazards, Vol. 99, pp. 1131–1161. https://doi.org/10.1007/s11069-019-03761-7
Saaty, T. L. (2003). Decision-making with the AHP: Why is the principal eigenvector necessary. European journal of operational research, 145(1), 85-91.
Sadler, R. C., Arku, G., & Gilliland, J. A. (2015). Local food networks as catalysts for food policy change to improve health and build the economy. Local Environment, 20(9), 1103-1121.
Schmeltz, M. T., Petkova, E. P., & Gamble, J. L. (2016). Economic Burden of Hospitalizations for Heat-Related Illnesses in the United States, 2001-2010. International Journal of Environmental Research and Public Health, Vol. 13(9), pp 894.
Schmitt-Olabisi, L. S., Wentworth, C., Key, K., Wallace, R. V., McNall, M., Hodbod, J., & Gray, S. A. (2023). Defining success in community-university partnerships: lessons learned from Flint. Journal of Responsible Innovation, 10(1), 2102567.
Schmitt-Olabisi, L., McNall, M., Porter, W., & Zhao, J. (Eds.). (2020). Innovations in collaborative modeling. MSU Press.
Sellberg, M. M., Ryan, P., Borgström, S. T., Norström, A. V., & Peterson, G. D. (2018). From resilience thinking to Resilience Planning: Lessons from practice. Journal of environmental management, 217, 906-918.
Stewart, T. (2005). Dealing with uncertainties in MCDA. Multiple criteria decision analysis: state of the art surveys,Springer-Verlag, New York . , Vol. 78, pp. 445-466.
Stover, V. W., & McCormack, E. D. (2012). The Impact of Weather on Bus Ridership in Pierce County, Washington. Journal of Public Transportation, 15(1), 95-110.
Stringer, L. C., Dougill, A. J., Fraser, E., Hubacek, K., Prell, C., & Reed, M. S. (2006). Unpacking “participation” in the adaptive management of social–ecological systems: a critical review. Ecology and Society, Vol. 11(2). pp 39-61.
Thilmany, D., Brislen, L., Edmondson, H., Gill, M., Jablonski, B. B., Rossi, J., Woods, T., & Schaffstall, S. (2021). Novel methods for an interesting time: Exploring US local food systems’ impacts and initiatives to respond to COVID. Australian Journal of Agricultural and Resource Economics, 65(4), 848-877.
United States Census Bureau (USCB). (2022). QuickFacts: Flint city, Michigan. Census Bureau QuickFacts. https://www.census.gov/quickfacts/flintcitymichigan
Uphomes (2023), “What’s the cost of living in Michigan?”, Accessed at https://uphomes.com/blog/cost-of-living-michigan/.
USDOT. (2023). Benefit-Cost Analysis Guidance for Discretionary Grant Programs. Retrieved from https://www.transportation.gov/sites/dot.gov/files/2023-01/Benefit%20Cost%20Analysis%20Guidance%202023%20Update.pdf,
Van de Lindt, J. W., Kruse, J., Cox, D. T., Gardoni, P., Lee, J. S., Padgett, J., McAllister, T.P., Barbosa, A., Cutler, H., Van Zandt, S. & Hamideh, S. (2023). The interdependent networked community resilience modeling environment (IN-CORE). Resilient Cities and Structures, 2(2), 57-66.
Van Vliet, O., Hanger-Kopp, S., Nikas, A., Spijker, E., Carlsen, H., Doukas, H., & Lieu, J. (2020). The importance of stakeholders in scoping risk assessments—Lessons from low-carbon transitions. Environmental Innovation and Societal Transitions, 35, 400-413.
Vermeulen, S., Campbell, B. M., & Ingram, J. (2012). Climate Change and Food Systems. Annual Review of Environment and Resources, 37, 195-222.
Welsh, M. (2014). Resilience and responsibility: governing uncertainty in a complex world. The Geographical Journal, 180(1), 15-26.
Wentworth, C., Arroyo, M. T., Lembi, R. C., Feingold, B. J., Freedman, D., Gray, S., Hodbod, J., Jablonski, B.B., Janda-Thomte, K.M., Lemoine, P., Nielsen, A., & Yamoah, O. (2024). Navigating community engagement in participatory modeling of food systems. Environmental Science & Policy, 152, 103645.
Wentworth, C., Hodbod, J. & Drexler, L. (2022). Food System Values: Government and Philanthropic Perspectives. Flint Leverage Points Briefing Note 5. Flint, Michigan: Community Foundation of Greater Flint and Michigan State University.
Wentworth, C., Warsaw, P., Isaacs, K., Traore, A., Hammon, A., & Lewis, A. (2023). The resilience and viability of farmers markets in the United States as an alternative food network: case studies from Michigan during the COVID-19 pandemic. Agriculture and Human Values, 40(4), 1481-1496.
White, R., Stewart, B., & O’Neill, P. (2010). Access to Food in a Changing Climate. Environmental Change Institute, School of Geography and the Environment.
Worstell, J. (2020). Ecological resilience of food systems in response to the COVID-19 crisis. Journal of Agriculture, Food Systems, and Community Development, 9(3), 23-30.
Xu, Z. (2000). On consistency of the weighted geometric mean complex judgement matrix in AHP. European Journal of Operational Research, 126(3), 683-687.
Yi, S. S., Ali, S. H., Russo, R. G., Foster, V., Radee, A., Chong, S., Tsui, F., Kranick, J., Lee, D., Imbruce, V., & Mezzacca, T. A. (2022). COVID-19 leads to dramatic changes in the food retail environment in New York City: May–July 2020. Journal of Immigrant and Minority Health, Vol. 24(1), pp. 31-37.
Yue, M., & Kahn, G. (2019). A crash course on driving in the rain in L.A. https://xtown.la/2019/03/19/a-crash-course-on-driving-in-the-rain-in-la/
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial 4.0 International License.
Copyright (c) 2025 Mahdi Zareei, Carissa Knox, Jennifer Helgeson, Steven A. Gray, Richard C. Sadler, Laura Schmitt Olabisi, Chelsea Wentworth